Key Points

  • Visa and Mastercard are urging a U.S. judge to approve a $38 billion settlement resolving merchants’ claims over excessive credit-card processing fees.
  • The agreement would reduce swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and cap fees on standard consumer cards at 1.25% for eight years.
  • More than 1,000 objections have been filed, with opponents arguing the settlement does not create enough competition or adequately reduce fees on premium and commercial cards.
hero

 

Visa and Mastercard are pressing a U.S. federal judge to approve a proposed $38 billion settlement that would reshape how merchants pay to accept credit cards. The agreement could reduce processing costs for millions of businesses while changing longstanding rules governing which Visa and Mastercard products merchants must accept, but significant opposition remains over whether the reforms go far enough.

Settlement Would Reshape Merchant Card Fees

The proposed agreement would resolve a 21-year-old antitrust case in which merchants accused Visa, Mastercard and card-issuing banks of conspiring to maintain excessive “swipe fees,” also known as interchange fees.

The settlement covers more than 12 million merchants, although some opponents estimate that more than 20 million businesses could ultimately be affected. Visa and Mastercard have characterized the agreement as a significant compromise that would fundamentally change their relationships with merchants.

Under the proposal, the networks would reduce swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years and cap fees on standard consumer credit cards at 1.25% for eight years.

Merchants Would Gain Greater Flexibility

One of the most significant changes would be the end of the longstanding “Honor All Cards” rule. Merchants would gain the ability to reject certain categories of Visa and Mastercard cards while continuing to accept others, including popular rewards cards.

The proposal would divide cards into commercial cards, premium consumer cards such as rewards products, and standard consumer cards. Supporters argue that the new flexibility would give merchants greater control over their payment costs and strengthen their negotiating position with card networks.

The Merchants Payments Coalition said Visa and Mastercard swipe fees totaled $118.8 billion in the United States in 2025, up from $111.2 billion in 2024 and $25.6 billion in 2009. The average fee was 2.36%.

Opposition Centers on Competition

Despite the size of the proposed settlement, more than 1,000 objections have been submitted to the court, including objections from Walmart and the National Retail Federation.

Opponents argue that merchants would still face relatively high fees on premium consumer and commercial cards, which account for more than 90% of the card market. They also object to restrictions preventing merchants from choosing among individual card issuers, such as accepting cards from one bank while rejecting those from another.

Experts hired by the plaintiffs, including economist Joseph Stiglitz and University of Washington professor Keith Leffler, estimated that the changes could save merchants $38 billion by 2031 and generate $224 billion in broader benefits, including benefits for consumers.

Judge Signals a Lengthy Path if Settlement Is Rejected

U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan did not immediately rule on final approval during Monday’s hearing. However, he indicated that rejecting the agreement could lead to a protracted legal process if the 21-year-old case proceeds toward trial.

A previous $30 billion settlement was rejected by a different judge in June 2024 as insufficient. The latest proposal therefore faces a significant test as the court weighs the potential savings and flexibility for merchants against objections that it does not create meaningful structural competition.

For investors, the outcome could have implications beyond Visa and Mastercard. A final settlement would alter the economics of card payments across merchants, banks and consumers, while rejection could prolong regulatory and legal uncertainty. The court’s decision will therefore be closely watched for its potential impact on payment-network economics, merchant costs and competition across the U.S. credit-card market.


Comparison, examination, and analysis between investment houses

Leave your details, and an expert from our team will get back to you as soon as possible

    * This article, in whole or in part, does not contain any promise of investment returns, nor does it constitute professional advice to make investments in any particular field.

    To read more about the full disclaimer, click here
    SKN | Intel Faces Shareholder Lawsuit After 29% Stock Plunge Raises Disclosure Questions
    • Ronny Mor
    • •
    • 7 Min Read
    • •
    • ago 29 seconds

    SKN | Intel Faces Shareholder Lawsuit After 29% Stock Plunge Raises Disclosure Questions SKN | Intel Faces Shareholder Lawsuit After 29% Stock Plunge Raises Disclosure Questions

      Intel is facing a shareholder lawsuit following one of the sharpest single-day declines in its stock this year, adding

    • ago 29 seconds
    • •
    • 7 Min Read

      Intel is facing a shareholder lawsuit following one of the sharpest single-day declines in its stock this year, adding

    SKN | Nvidia Rules Out Jensen Huang Return as Campaign for His Reinstatement Grows
    • sagi habasov
    • •
    • 7 Min Read
    • •
    • ago 30 seconds

    SKN | Nvidia Rules Out Jensen Huang Return as Campaign for His Reinstatement Grows SKN | Nvidia Rules Out Jensen Huang Return as Campaign for His Reinstatement Grows

      Nvidia’s board is not considering a return for Jensen Huang as chief executive despite a growing campaign calling for

    • ago 30 seconds
    • •
    • 7 Min Read

      Nvidia’s board is not considering a return for Jensen Huang as chief executive despite a growing campaign calling for

    SKN | Bessent Calls for Outside CEO as Nvidia Faces Leadership and Governance Crisis
    • Arik Arkadi Sluzki
    • •
    • 6 Min Read
    • •
    • ago 1 day

    SKN | Bessent Calls for Outside CEO as Nvidia Faces Leadership and Governance Crisis SKN | Bessent Calls for Outside CEO as Nvidia Faces Leadership and Governance Crisis

      Nvidia is facing increasing pressure to overhaul its leadership following the abrupt departure of Jensen Huang, with U.S. Treasury

    • ago 1 day
    • •
    • 6 Min Read

      Nvidia is facing increasing pressure to overhaul its leadership following the abrupt departure of Jensen Huang, with U.S. Treasury

    SKN | Wingtech to Appeal Dutch Court Ruling in Ongoing Nexperia Ownership Dispute
    • Lior mor
    • •
    • 5 Min Read
    • •
    • ago 1 day

    SKN | Wingtech to Appeal Dutch Court Ruling in Ongoing Nexperia Ownership Dispute SKN | Wingtech to Appeal Dutch Court Ruling in Ongoing Nexperia Ownership Dispute

    Chinese technology company Wingtech Technology announced on Sunday that it will appeal an interim ruling by a Dutch court in

    • ago 1 day
    • •
    • 5 Min Read

    Chinese technology company Wingtech Technology announced on Sunday that it will appeal an interim ruling by a Dutch court in